Herbert Hoover top top the great Depression and brand-new Deal, 1931–1933

A Spotlight on a Primary resource by Herbert Hoover

The stock industry crashed ~ above Thursday, October 24, 1929, much less than eight months into Herbert Hoover’s presidency. Most experts, consisting of Hoover, believed the crash was part of a pass recession. By July 1931, when the President wrote this letter come a friend, governor Louis Emmerson that Illinois, that had end up being clear that extreme speculation and a worldwide economic slowdown had actually plunged America right into the midst of a good Depression. If Hoover composed to Emmerson that "considerable continue of destitution end the winter" and perhaps longer was unavoidable, he was trying come "get machine of the nation into . . . Action." because the crash, Hoover had worked ceaselessly trying to solve the economy. He established government agencies, encouraged labor harmony, sustained local help for windy works, cultivated cooperation between government and business in order to stabilize prices, and struggled to balance the budget. His work concentrated on indirect relief from individual states and also the personal sector, as reflected in this letter’s emphasis on "support every state committee much more effectively" and also volunteerism—"appeal because that funds" from outside the government.

You are watching: The policy of volunteerism called for which of the following

As the Depression ended up being worse, however, calls prospered for enhanced federal intervention and spending. But Hoover refused to show off the federal federal government in forcing fixed prices, regulating businesses, or manipulating the worth of the currency, all of which that felt were procedures towards socialism. He was inclined to offer indirect help to financial institutions or regional public works projects, however he refused to usage federal money because that direct aid to citizens, believing the dole would weaken public morale. Instead, he concentrated on volunteerism to raise money. Hoover’s adversaries painted him as uncaring towards the typical citizen, even though he to be in fact a philanthropist and also a gradual before coming to be president. Throughout his reelection campaign, Hoover make the efforts to to convince Americans that the actions they to be calling for could seem to aid in the quick term, however would be ruinous in the long run. The asserted the he cared for typical Americans too much to damage the country’s structures with deficits and also socialist institutions. He to be soundly defeated by Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1932.

Roosevelt promised american a "New Deal" when he take it office, and during his an initial "Hundred Days" as president, he signed a variety of groundbreaking new laws. Roosevelt’s aides later admitted the most brand-new Deal organ were carefully modeled top top those the Hoover had attempted, however Roosevelt’s plans differed in financing and scope. New Deal receipt supported straight federal aid, tightened government regulate over many industries, and also eschewed volunteerism in donate of deficit spending, all in the really hopes of jump beginning both customer confidence and also the economy.

In a letter come a friend written 7 months after the left office, Hoover to express his fears about the flurry of brand-new Deal legislation. Hoover observed the country already "going tart on the brand-new Deal." the believed transformation inevitable "unless over there is a halt" to the basic changes in government and also the deficit spending. Roosevelt’s reforms had actually led american to "cast off every moorings," and also Hoover predicted that the United claims would veer dangerously "to the ‘left,’" complied with by a reaction resulting in "some American translate of Hitler or Mussolini." In 1934, after 2 years the end of the general public eye, Hoover make these very same thoughts public in an short article titled "The challenge to Liberty."

Hoover to be correct when he predicted the the role of American government would fundamentally readjust because that the new Deal.

A full transcript is accessible for Hoover’s letter come Louis Emmerson.


Herbert Hoover to Louis L. Emmerson, July 10, 1931

July 10, 1931


Hon. Luigi L. EmmersonGovernor that IllinoisSpringfield, Ill.

My dear branch Emmerson:

No issue what improvement there might be in ours economic instance during the fall, us shall unquestionably have significant continuance the destitution end the winter. I am wondering if it would not be recipient for united state to gain the machine of the country into earlier activity than critical year in order that there may be provision for funds substantially made prior to the winter arrives.

Your organization last winter was among the many admirable in the whole country and also I had actually some thought that if all organizations were to begin their appeals for funds part time in October and also run them over Thanksgiving we might make it much more or less a national question and also thereby assistance each state committee an ext effectively.

This, however, is just thinking great on the general situation and also I would favor your views.

I great again come express mine appreciation because that the good courtesies we obtained at the hands of Mrs. Emmerson and also yourself and with sort regards come you both, ns am

Yours faithfully,Herbert Hoover


A fulltranscript is obtainable for Hoover’s letter come Bruce Barton.


Herbert Hoover come Bruce Barton, October 3, 1933

October 3, 1933


My dear Barton:

I have actually compiled v your momentous wish. Your friend go not should send an exchange. A cigarette smoking President receives enough pipes to last a life time. Likewise fishing tackle. The is the only endowment he gets, other than a troubled soul.

It appears useless to comment on the situation. The nation is going tart on the new Deal, regardless of the heroic initiatives of the Press. Unless there is a halt, the real question will be that, having cast off every moorings, will we swing come the "right" or come the "left". Ns fear very first the "left" and then when the great middle class (80% of America) realizes that is ruin, it will certainly drive right into some American translate of Hitler or Mussolini.

See more: Man With Black Hair And Green Eyes, Male Models With Black Hair And Green Eyes

There is no problem finding a big occupation in California act nothing and also conducting a detached observatory of national trends.