Playing videogames, I regularly see katana as an obtainable weapon. Looking about the web, you can often discover Katana, Tanto, Kunai and also a many other japanese weapons... But rarely something chinese. I think the only place I uncovered a chinese sword used was a chinese videogame.

You are watching: Chinese swords vs japanese swords

Why room chinese blades not as famous as japanese ones? Or is the a case that chinese swords room not together "good" together japanese ones? ( i mean, I regularly heard about how incredible japanese blacksmiths were, and that they created techniques i m sorry made chisels so significant they can't be replicated even with today's technology).

Sorry if this is no the ar for this or if it is a stupid question. It's just something i noticed in pop-culture and I hoped to find a reason.


15 comments
share
save
hide
report
82% Upvoted
Log in or authorize up to leaving a comment
Log InSign Up
Sort by: best


*

level 1
· 2y
Anime


15
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 2
Op · 2y

That an easy uh?


5
Reply
Share
ReportSave
Continue this thread 


level 1
· 2y
Media in general. Ninjas, samurai movies, anime, myths and legends, stories


6
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 2y

I think you need to go back to WW2 and before. Western servicemen brought back a most katana together trophies native the war. Even before the war, the Japanese used their swords as course symbols much much more consistently than the Chinese did. There is also a layout in 19th Century works that Chinese armed forces professionals and also martial artists were looked under upon by the top classes.


4
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 2y
Xiphos and also Sting look at cool

This video discussed that specific topic, have actually a look.


5
Reply
Share
ReportSave
level 1
· 2y · edited 2y

Japanese swords space not superior to many swords. Castle are an excellent for what they space intended to and that's it. Lock have benefits and drawbacks simply like any type of other sword. A katana would be the dorn weapon come fight a so late european knight for instance. And also that's no problem due to the fact that it never had to. That's why the europe swords later developed into thrusting swords - i beg your pardon in fact were inferior in your cutting capacity since cutting acquired less important. That's exactly how the estoc and also tuc involved life. Dull blades however pointy as hell, however for one unarmed duell not an especially fitting.

The same goes because that chinese swords. They are great for what they were intended to do. Chinese fighting styles and also armed kung fu. They room neither inferiour to japanese weapons, no one to european weapons.

The katana probably is so popular since it acquired a big myth built about it in movies and also fiction. They were glorified a lot in miscellaneous movies and books. Maybe because the traditional method of making a katana is very special. Maybe since people have this picture of the unbeatable martial arts experienced who in japanese culture also wields a sword. Maybe since japansese swordsmanship has actually something very spiritual come it. It might have miscellaneous reasons.

But the katana has a the majority of his popularity due to the wave of Ninja films for instance which were an extremely popular and also painted a photo of those almost superhuman martial artist masters that would only wield the ideal of the ideal weapons. Later those movie ninjas began wielding a more straighter blade, i beg your pardon was dubbed a ninjato. Most likely a completely fictional sword, yet nevertheless did this sword probably add a lot to the legend of the ninja warrior and also to the legend of the katana. The popularity of anime and also manga probably added to this too because there space some insane points which personalities tend to carry out with katana choose cutting steel and also stone.

Maybe it likewise helped the there are a many misconceptions around european and chinese swords. Most world think of medieval european swords together blund beaters which are meant to placed dents into hefty armor. And also quite a most those people also have those whippy wushu chisels which shaolin mirrors use for phase combat and also training in mental if castle think around chinese swords.

If hollywood had picked the chinese sword as your mythical sword, things might have turned out different. Then people might think of the jian as the super knife which can cut through steel and also armor and also which is light together a feather. I think the katana acquired his state as result of misconceptions around other swords and a lucky hollywood history. And I likewise kind of gain why, since some katanas are true art pieces. Not that chinese or europe swords aren't, but due to the fact that a katana is so quick for a 2 handed weapon and thick rather of wide, that looks very nimble and also wieldy.

If friend look in ~ the albion maximilan because that instance, it's the other method around. That looks heavy and also beefy but it's in reality a nimble and also wieldy blade.

See more: Buy Bunny Ear Hat With Free Shipping On Aliexpress, Hat Bunny Ears

Note that all this is based upon my opinion and also on a the majority of assumptions, for this reason this isn't a identify "This is exactly how it has actually been and nothing different".