Despite the passionate counter-statement “There space no stupid questions!”, over there absolutely are concerns that invite a stupid answer.

You are watching: Ask a stupid question get a stupid answer

How does the happen?

All as well easily.

A concern asked without giving context for just how the answer will be used substantially reduces the likelihood the there will certainly be a real exchange of relevant information.

Which is a long means of speak that, without context, a question begs for a not-very-useful answer (a.k.a. A stupid answer).

It’s not the fault of the person answering; that the error of the human being asking.

I think we’ve all experienced just how frustrating that is to be asked something without any context, but here space two short examples.

At a party part years ago, someone came rushing right into the kitchen asking for a towel.

Responding usefully to the request was impossible without understanding what the towel to be for: to wipe a baby’s face, dried a plate, or – as was the instance in this example – clean increase dog slobber? Or something else entirely?

I newly spoke through a partner who had actually been asked about the job close-out process she’d done for a client. My partner was provided no understanding (no context) right into why the concern was gift asked; she was just told the the client’s Program administration office was requesting the information.

Needless come say, even though she knew the project had gone smoothly, my colleague spent number of days through a node in her stomach wonder if she’d excellent something wrong. Furthermore, her answer was a bare-bones recital of the facts; without knowing the why behind the concern (the context), she had no way to ensure the her answer to be relevant and also complete.

Asking because that a bath towel without providing input right into why you desire the towel means there’s a high likelihood of getting the wrong kind of towel. One no wipe dog slobber off the floor v a towel intended because that your an excellent china.

Asking because that project-closeout measures without giving input into why you want that details will, again, elicit a potentially incomplete and also not-very-useful answer. My colleague never ever did find out the “why” in this case. If she had known, she nearly certainly would have been able to provide extr information that might have offered totally different insights for the civilization asking.

See more: 9781561841172: Condensed Chaos: An Introduction To Chaos Magic Paperback

“Ask a contextless question, get an irrelevant answer” isn’t as catchy as the initial phrase, yet it’s more accurate and more useful.